My Forever Songs review
Our verdict: 2.85 / 5, #12 of 19 on our twelve checks. You pay first, then hear it. From $39. No delivery time is stated. In its own words: “Tell us your story — the inside jokes, the memories, the moments that matter”. No Trustpilot profile with reviews.
My Forever Songs ranks #12 of 19. The twelve checks are below, each with the service's own words and the page we read.
Weights: price 15, hear-first 15, emotion 15, speed 10, what arrives 10, the rest 5 each. How we rate.
Best for
- The full pack: more than an audio file
- Sending on a chosen date
Skip it if
- The day is this week
- You need to hear it before paying
- You want public reviews to lean on
Every fact, with the words it came from.
Tap a check to see the fact, the service's own quote, and the page we read, with the date.
Price of the full gift
From $39 for the first song.
- Full song unlock ('$39 flat'), $39: Full song, synced lyrics, lyric files, cover art, gift delivery tools, unlimited re-dos after unlock, full refund if it misses
Prices shown in USD; no conversion needed.
“Unlock the full song for $39. Your song arrives by email with unlimited re-dos and a full refund if it misses.”
Speed (their claim)
Not stated. Their claim: not stated (song 'arrives by email' after unlock; no turnaround time published)
“Song delivered By email after unlock”
Hear it before you pay
You pay before you hear it. Homepage FAQ states you do not hear your own song before paying. Occasion pages and the pricing blog use 'preview' wording ('hear a real preview once you unlock', 'Full preview after checkout, by email'), i.e. the preview comes after checkout. Public 30-second demo songs (not yours) are playable on the homepage and occasion pages.
“Not in this flow — you unlock first, then your song arrives by email.”
What arrives
You get an audio download, artwork, a lyric sheet, a page to share. Support page describes: MP3 download ('the MP3 is usually saved in Files or Downloads'), lyric sheet PDF in A4 or US Letter with your photo, a 'Keepsake' with cover photo, a gift page with shareable link, 'Send by email' with a note, revision history, and in some packages a 'second song' in another style. Video and physical products are not mentioned.
“You get the full song, synced lyrics, lyric files, cover art, gift delivery tools, and unlimited revisions after unlock.”
Emotion and sound (samples + reviews)
No Trustpilot profile with reviews. 8 public samples (listen). We have not auditioned a bought song; this score is from samples and public reviews.
Schedule the gift
Yes. After unlock the gift email can be sent instantly or scheduled for a chosen morning; a link can also be copied and shared manually.
“After unlock you can send the song instantly or schedule the email delivery for the morning of the anniversary.”
Voice input
Voice input (tell the story by voice): Not stated. Order flow is an 8-step questionnaire ('Step 1 of 8: Who's this song for?'); we saw only step 1. No voice-note input or own-voice option is mentioned on any page we checked.
“Answer a few questions and we'll create a personalized song.”
Revisions
Unlimited re-dos after unlock (one blog page says up to 3 refinements).
“Request unlimited fresh full-song versions until it feels right. If it still misses, get a full refund.”
Streaming release
Not stated.
Gifting
Offers gift page, email delivery, a note. 'Gift & share' lets the buyer choose the opening song, included recordings and a note, preview what the recipient sees, copy the link, or 'Send by email' (instantly or scheduled). 'A saved draft is not an emailed gift.'
Trust (public reviews)
No Trustpilot profile with reviews. Trustpilot profile claimed Mar 2026 but 0 reviews, TrustScore 0.0. Self-hosted claims: '10,000+ songs created', first-name testimonials on /stories. Do not confuse with foreversongs.com (Trustpilot 4.9, ~17.6k reviews) or myforeversong.co (Trustpilot 2.8 from 3 reviews): the support page itself says 'Trying to reach another company called Forever Songs? We can access My Forever Songs orders only.' A competitor's article also tells the three apart. No third-party Reddit thread about myforeversongs.com found.
Transparency
Some basics are not stated on the site; see what the site does not say, below. 8 open questions in total.
What the site does not say
Open questions after reading the homepage, pricing and help pages. If you need one of these, ask the service before ordering.
- Delivery turnaround time (only 'by email after unlock'; receipt apparently states a timing)
- Prices of packages or extras beyond the $39 unlock (support mentions 'second style' packages and 'optional extras')
- Who or what produces the vocals and music (site says 'professionally produced', 'real vocals', 'streamlined production flow')
- Video output; physical products
- Streaming release (Spotify / Apple Music / YouTube)
- Languages; genre list (only 'choose the vibe' in the flow; steps 2–8 not seen)
- Voice-note story input
- Revision limit: 'unlimited' on most pages vs 'up to 3 refinements' in the pricing blog table
On their site
Four to compare it with.
The services just above and below it in the ranking.
You pay before you hear it. Ready in 1 to 7 days. From $179. Trustpilot 4.5 from 23,606 reviews.
You pay before you hear it. Ready in minutes. From $10. No Trustpilot profile with reviews.
You hear a sample before you pay. Ready in 1 hour to 7 days. From $79. Trustpilot 4.8 from 3,903 reviews.
You pay before you hear it. Ready in 1 to 3 days. From $39.90. Trustpilot 3.7 from 6 reviews.
Questions about My Forever Songs
Do I hear the song before I pay with My Forever Songs?
You pay before you hear it. Homepage FAQ states you do not hear your own song before paying. Occasion pages and the pricing blog use 'preview' wording ('hear a real preview once you unlock', 'Full preview after checkout, by email'), i.e. the preview comes after checkout. Public 30-second demo songs (not yours) are playable on the homepage and occasion pages.
How much does My Forever Songs cost?
From $39 for the first song, as shown on its site on 28 October 2026. Prices shown in USD; no conversion needed.
How long does My Forever Songs take?
not stated (song 'arrives by email' after unlock; no turnaround time published) That is the service's own claim, checked 28 October 2026.
Who makes the song at My Forever Songs?
In its own words: “Tell us your story — the inside jokes, the memories, the moments that matter”. We repeat the service's own words and nothing more.
Is My Forever Songs legit?
My Forever Songs runs at myforeversongs.com. Its site states a price ($39) and a delivery time (not stated). No Trustpilot profile with reviews. Its site leaves 8 questions open, listed on this page. This is what its public pages showed on 28 October 2026; we have not bought from every service.
Before you order
You order on their site; we only link you there. Rankings are never paid for.
Worth a read first: What a custom song costs · Who writes the song · Is a song a good gift? · Make it yourself or buy?
Where a song like this fits.
A few occasions people buy song gifts for, each with what to put in the story and when to order.
Ready to try My Forever Songs?
#12 of 19 on our twelve checks. Or see how it stacks up against the rest.